Skip to main content

Providing independent clinical excellence since 2005

The SCVC Blog

Cardiovascular care news and articles from our expert team

Beyond the Heart: Should We Be Screening for Cancer Before Symptoms Develop?

Posted on Monday November 2, 2026 in Diagnostic & Health Screening

Beyond the Heart: Should We Be Screening for Cancer Before Symptoms Develop?

Advances in cardiovascular prevention are reshaping how proactive clinics think about cancer detection — and what that means for your patients and yourself.

Declaration of interest: this article mentions services provided by Surrey Cardiovascular Clinic. Dr Edward Leatham founded SCVC and is its majority shareholder, and has financial interests in some of the services it uses. Full disclosures →

For busy people, or to tune in when on the move, a Google NotebookLM audio podcast is available as a story beneath.

From Cardiovascular Prevention to a Broader View of Health

The patient sitting in front of me had no symptoms. He was fifty-four, a non-smoker, with a total cholesterol his GP had declared entirely satisfactory and a blood pressure hovering just below the threshold for treatment. By every conventional metric, he was fine. A coronary CT scan told a different story: significant plaque burden in his left anterior descending artery, and a fat attenuation index measurement placing him in a high-risk category for a cardiovascular event within the next decade. He left that appointment on a statin, an antihypertensive, and with a clear plan — and asking a question I now hear regularly: if we can find heart disease before it causes symptoms, why can’t we do the same for cancer?

It is a reasonable question, and one that has fundamentally shaped how Surrey Cardiovascular Clinic has evolved. Central to our preventive programme is the Fat Attenuation Index, or FAI — developed at Oxford and commercialised by Caristo Diagnostics — which uses information already contained within a standard coronary CT to assess inflammation in the fat surrounding the coronary arteries. The landmark CRISP-CT study, published in The Lancet in 2018, demonstrated that elevated FAI was associated with significantly increased cardiovascular mortality over five years. The ORFAN study, published in The Lancet in 2024, extended and strengthened that association, establishing FAI as a clinically meaningful prognostic tool.

The Case for Multi-Cancer Early Detection — and Its Limits

The same metabolic milieu that accelerates coronary atherosclerosis is also associated with an increased risk of colorectal, pancreatic, and endometrial malignancies. It was this overlap in risk profile that led SCVC to introduce the Galleri multi-cancer early detection blood test as an optional component of its proactive health screening programme.

Galleri, developed by GRAIL, detects cell-free DNA shed by tumour cells and uses methylation patterns to predict where in the body a signal originates, across more than fifty cancer types, the majority of which have no current NHS screening programme.

The PATHFINDER 2 study reported a positive predictive value of approximately forty percent, which compares favourably with most screening tests in unselected populations. The NHS-Galleri trial, enrolling approximately one hundred and forty thousand participants, was more sobering: detection rates were meaningful, but the trial was not powered to demonstrate a reduction in cancer mortality within its initial reporting period, and the NHS concluded the evidence was insufficient for population-wide adoption.

This is not a reason to dismiss Galleri — it is a reason to counsel patients honestly. A negative result does not exclude cancer; sensitivity across all stages, particularly stage one, remains incomplete. The NHS’s caution reflects legitimate concerns about population-scale economics and false-positive harm. It does not negate the potential value of the test for an informed, motivated individual who understands its limitations and would act on an early signal if one were found.

Men’s Health, Prostate Cancer, and the PSA Dilemma

The clinical overlap I see most consistently is in men in their mid-forties to mid-sixties presenting with visceral obesity, borderline testosterone, insulin resistance, erectile dysfunction, and declining energy. Erectile dysfunction in a man of fifty with cardiovascular risk factors is not simply a quality-of-life issue — it is frequently an early marker of endothelial dysfunction, the same process that precedes clinically apparent coronary artery disease. I treat it as a prompt for thorough cardiac assessment.

The NHS does not operate a national prostate cancer screening programme. The major European randomised trial, ERSPC, showed a significant reduction in prostate cancer mortality with PSA screening, but at the cost of substantial overdiagnosis. What has shifted the calculus is the widespread adoption of multiparametric prostate MRI and the PI-RADS scoring system, which stratifies findings from one to five by suspicion level. An abnormal PSA now typically leads to MRI before biopsy, substantially reducing unnecessary invasive investigation. For men who understand this landscape, an informed decision-making conversation is entirely appropriate. The NHS’s position reflects the difficulty of rolling this out equitably at population scale. It does not mean an informed individual should be denied the opportunity to decide for himself.

Key Takeaways

1

The Fat Attenuation Index, derived from coronary CT imaging and validated in the CRISP-CT and ORFAN Lancet studies, adds prognostic information about coronary inflammation that conventional risk scores do not capture, and is already available in specialist preventive cardiology programmes.

2

The Galleri multi-cancer early detection test shows meaningful promise in appropriately selected patients, but a negative result does not exclude cancer, and any positive result requires careful clinical interpretation rather than immediate alarm — honest pre-test counselling is essential.

3

Erectile dysfunction in a middle-aged man with cardiovascular risk factors should prompt proactive cardiac assessment, not solely urological referral, because it frequently reflects early endothelial dysfunction that predates overt coronary disease.

4

PSA testing for prostate cancer remains outside NHS population screening because of overdiagnosis risk, but the improved diagnostic pathway offered by multiparametric MRI and PI-RADS scoring means that an informed man requesting PSA discussion deserves a structured, evidence-based conversation rather than a blanket refusal.
Summary
As cardiovascular medicine becomes better at predicting and preventing heart disease, cancer has emerged as the greater threat to long-term health. This article explores the evidence behind multi-cancer early detection blood tests and PSA screening, their real limitations, and why proactive cardiovascular clinics are leading this broader conversation.

Related Blog Articles

  1. Cardiologists and a New Enemy: Evolving Tools of the Trade

https://www.scvc.co.uk/diagnostic-health-screening/cardiologists-evolving-tools/

  1. Three game changing technologies in 2023

https://www.scvc.co.uk/diagnostic-health-screening/game-changing-cardiology-technologies-2023/

  1. Understanding Coronary Heart Disease: From Early Inflammation to Modern CT Imaging

https://www.scvc.co.uk/diagnostic-health-screening/types-of-ct-to-diagnose-chd/

  1. Can we use AI to predict cardiovascular death

https://www.vat-trap.com/post/can-we-use-ai-to-predict-cardiovascular-death

  1. Why a cardiovascular clinic started running men’s health clinics

https://www.scvc.co.uk/diagnostic-health-screening/mens-health-cardiovascular-clinic/

Blog post:

https://www.scvc.co.uk/diagnostic-health-screening/cancer-screening-cardiovascular-prevention/

Referenced version (UK English only):

https://mhaat.vercel.app/s-cancer-screening-cardiovascular-prevention.html

Wix / SCVC embeds — supplied as separate files in the download, not in this document:

s-cancer-screening-cardiovascular-prevention-aicp-ref-embed.html  —  referenced-edition card + AI Companion Pack (top of the article)

s-cancer-screening-cardiovascular-prevention-aicp-embed.html  —  AI Companion Pack only

More articles for you